Nov. 23, 2025

November 21, 2025

Anabaptism At Five Hundred


First Mennonite Church

Sugarcreek, Ohio

November 23, 2025



Worship: 9:30 – 10:30

Fellowship Time: 10:30 – 12:00

We believe in Jesus and take his life, teachings, death and resurrection

as the model for how we live and the message we proclaim.

***************************************

We seek to be a caring and discerning community,  the gathered body of Christ that welcomes all to join in worship, study, and service.

*********************************************

We embody God’s transforming and redeeming Spirit in the world

through our prophetic witness and action.

 

THE CHURCH WORSHIPS TOGETHER


Anabaptism at 500

Belief  Nine: Communion

 

~Gathering in the Royal Bible Classroom~

(around tables)


Welcome and Announcements

 

Focus Statement: 

The Lord’s Supper is the last meal that Jesus shared with his disciples

before he was crucified on the cross. While eating this meal of bread and

wine, Jesus said, “Do this in remembrance of me.” Communion is the

religious practice of sharing bread and wine (or juice) as part of a

worship service. Anabaptists in the sixteenth century differed from the

state churches in their understanding of communion. Anabaptists

understood the bread and cup as symbols of the body and blood of Jesus,

rather than believing that an actual transformation of the elements

took place. Anabaptists shared communion as a way to remember and

renew their commitment to the church community and to the teachings

of Jesus. Anabaptists also began the practice of serving communion to

one another, instead of requiring a priest to do so. This understanding

of ministering to one another is known as the Priesthood of All

Believers.


Scripture: Luke 22:19-20

“Then he took a loaf of bread, and when he had given thanks,

he broke it and gave it to them, saying,

‘This is my body, which is given for you.

Do this in remembrance of me.’

And he did the same with the cup after supper, saying,

‘This cup that is poured out for you is the

new covenant in my blood.’”

 

Time of Meditation: HWB 94 Come, Ye Thankful People

 

Call to Worship:  

 Leader: As God’s people, we have gathered. We may be discouraged,

               dismayed, discordant with life.

 People:  Let us sit together, sharing the solace of silence. Let us

               possess the peace of God’s presence and be wrapped in the

               warmth of God’s love. Let us be comforted and quieted,

               prepared for communion with God and fellowship with one

               another.

 

Invocation

 

Hymn of Gathering: HWB 17 We Gather Together

 

~Storytelling~

  

Early Anabaptist Story from Martyrs Mirror:

   Story about the Sacraments – read by April Shupe

 

Early Anabaptist Story in Drama #1:

Medicine for Christ’s Body?: Pilgram Marpeck, 1531

Narrator –Hannah Gehman, Spiritualist – Mike Gehman,

Marpeck – Reno Stevanus

 

 

~Praising and Praying~


Hymn of Praise: HWB 86 Now Thank We All Our

 

Prayers of the People

 

~Storytelling and Communion~


Global Story: Cheyenne Peace Chief Lawrence Hart

                        read by – Helene Torgler

 

Scripture: Colossians 3:1-17 

  Reader 1 – Bertie Showers

  Reader 2 – Bruce Stauffer

  Reader 3 – Nancy Yoder

 

Hymn: HWB 453 Let Us Break Bread Together

 

From the Schleitheim Confession, Article Third.

Concerning the breaking of bread we have become one and agree thus…

  – read by Suzanne Stauffer

 

Communion Service

(sharing of the bread and the cup with each other)

 

 

Invitation to the Communion Table

  Leader: As John baptized Jesus in the Jordan, the Holy Spirit   

               baptized the body of Christ. God now gathers us at

               these tables as the body of Christ to hear the voice of

               heaven, spoken over the waters of baptism, saying,

               “You are my beloved.”

  People:  Water, bread, and wine, the gifts of the earth, the gifts of the

                church, reveal that we belong with God and one another.

Leader:  Come with your hunger. Come with your thirst.

      ALL: This is Christ’s table. This is our feast. Come, Holy Spirit!

 

 Communion Prayer—Inspired by Early Christian Practice

 Leader: May God be with you!

 People: And also with you.

 Leader: Lift up your hearts!

 People: We lift them up to God.

 Leader: Let us give thanks to God.

 People: It is good to give thanks and praise.

 Leader: It is a good and joyful thing always and everywhere to give

                thanks to you, Holy One. With your people on earth and all

                the company of heaven we praise your name and join their

                unending hymn:

  ALL:  Holy, holy, holy, God of power and might, heaven and earth

            are full of your glory. Hosanna in the highest. Blessed is the

            one who comes in your name. Hosanna in the highest.

 Leader:  And so we proclaim this mystery of faith:

     ALL:  Christ has died. Christ is risen. Christ will come again.

 Leader:  We praise you, all holy God, the Father, the Son, the Holy

                Spirit, today, tomorrow, and forever. Amen!

     ALL:   Amen!

 Leader: Let us pray together the Lord’s Prayer: 

Our Father, who art in heaven, hallowed be thy name.

Thy kingdom come. Thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven.

Give us this day our daily bread and forgive us our trespasses

as we forgive those who trespass against us.

And lead us not into temptation.

But deliver us from evil. For thine is the kingdom,

and the power, and the glory forever. Amen.

 

 Leader:  The gifts of God for the people of God.

 People:  Thanks be to God.

(Share the bread and cup.)

 

~Responding~


Prayer after Communion – Iona Community

 Leader:  In deep gratitude for this moment, this time together, these

                people, we give ourselves to you.

 People: Send us to live as changed people because we have shared

               the Living Bread and cannot remain the same. Ask much of

               us, expect much from us, enable much by us, encourage

               many through us.

       All:  So, God, may we glorify you as inhabitants of earth and

              citizens of heaven. Amen.

 

Hymn of Response:  HWB 472 I am the Bread of Life v. 1, 4, 5

                                  HWB 96 We Plow the Fields and Scatter

 

~Sending~

   

Benediction

 

Sending Hymn: VT 812 Sent Forth by God’s Blessing

 

Sending Words:

   ALL:  We’ve seen diversity as a sign of love, and so we put on

               love and live as one.

 

(The Passing of the Peace)


WORSHIP                                                                          9:30-10:30                                                                                            

Minister:                                                                                   Mike Gehman

Worship Leader:                                                                       Dan Hostetler      

 Pianist:                                                                         Suzanne Stauffer

Head Usher:                                                                       Leadership Team

                               

Our On-Going Series on Anabaptist Beliefs:

In 2018 Lisa Weaver and Elizabeth Miller, as part of the Bearing Witness Stories project, wrote a book for children entitled Let the

Children Come to Me: Nurturing Anabaptist Faith within Families.

 

“The materials gathered together in this book beautifully

illustrate the central convictions of the Anabaptist tradition.”     

-John D. Roth, Director of the Institute for the

Study of Global Anabaptism

 

As residents of Holmes and Tuscarawas counties, oftentimes we each have been asked, “Are Mennonites Amish?” and “What do you believe that’s different from other Protestant denominations?” It’s sometimes

hard to come up with an explanation of our faith. Hopefully this series of worship services (that will be spread out through this year of Anabaptism at 500) will enable us to answer these questions more accurately. We are basing this series on the above-mentioned book.

 

In conjunction with our Anabaptist at Five Hundred celebration this year, we  would love to have pictures of any community, service and/or peace experiences our church members have experienced over the years. Please give to April or Tabby who will scan them into the computer.   You will  get them back.


FMC LIVES IN DISCIPLESHIP TOGETHER

Mission Project for November: Dover-Phila Food Bank

The Dover-New Phila Food Pantry’s mission is simple: No one in need is ever turned away, and recipients can come anytime they are open and from anywhere. They are a community-based food pantry supported by the community. Please make out checks to FMC and Bruce will send one check at the end of the month to the Food Bank. 

 

Special Thanksgiving / Christmas Project: Garaway Pirate Power Packs

The Garaway Pirate Power Pack Program, sponsored by the Sugarcreek United Church of Christ, meets monthly to pack over 350 bags full of food for local students. We will be collecting the following items over the next several weeks to help provide food for this program: 

Ramen noodles                       cans of corn                       cans of green beans

        cans of ravioli                     cans of tomato soup          cans of pork and beans

cans of chicken noodle soup

 

 

Bill & Jean Flinner new address: 1000 Addington Dr. Apt. 129

                                                   Russell, KY 41169

 

THE CHURCH GIVES THANKS

April Shupe: Thankful that Darcy Miller and Mike Gehman are both here with us today.

Sue Stauffer: Jim Cahill is finished with his chemo, he needs infusions but is starting to feel better.

 

THE CHURCH PRAYS FOR

Tabatha Murphy: Dylan’s grandma, Malinda Hamilton, had abdominal surgery, prayers for a speedy recovery.

April Shupe: Melanie Blauch Archer has diverticulitis, also Dick Douthitt is in the hospital.

 

THIS WEEK

Nov. 25th                    Happy Birthday, Suzie Armstrong

Nov. 30th                   Advent Begins


NEXT WEEK       

Minister:                                                                                                    Mike Gehman

Worship Leader:                                                                                           April Shupe

Head Usher:                                                                                         Leadership Team                                                                               

 

LAST WEEK

Attendance:                                                                                                      23

Offering:                                                                                                            $1533

Change for a dollar:                                                                                         $22.03

 

CHURCH LEADERSHIP

Pastor: Mike Gehman: 1-330-749-674

Email: pastor@firstmennonitesugarcreek.com

Pastor’s Hours: Wednesday 9:30a.m.-2:30p.m

Church Secretary: Tabatha Murphy

Phone: 1-330-852-2822

Email: office@firstmennonitesugarcreek.com

Website: http//fmcsugarcreekoh.org

Address: 113 W. Main St. P.O. Box 250 Sugarcreek, Ohio 44681

 

CONGREGATIONAL LEADERSHIP TEAM:

Chairperson: Mike Keim

Office Contact: Linda Yoder

Mission Contact: Reno Stevanus

Trustees Contact: Dan Hostetler

Secretary Contact: Amy Stauffer-McNutt

March 27, 2026
The body content of your post goes here. To edit this text, click on it and delete this default text and start typing your own or paste your own from a different source.
March 20, 2026
Lent Five: Complicity and Innocence  First Mennonite Church Sugarcreek, Ohio March 22, 2026 Worship: 9:30 am Coffee & Fellowship Time: 10:30 am We believe in Jesus and take his life, teachings, death and resurrection as the model for how we live and the message we proclaim. ***************************************­ We seek to be a caring and discerning community, the gathered body of Christ, that welcomes all to join in worship, study, and service. ****************************************** We embody God’s transforming and redeeming Spirit in the world through our prophetic witness and action. THE CHURCH WORSHIPS TOGETHER “Patient Trust” by Pierre Teilhard de Chardin We are quite naturally impatient in everything to reach the end without delay. We should like to skip the intermediate stages. We are impatient of being on the way to something unknown, something new. And yet it is the law of all progress that it is made by passing through some stages of instability— and that it may take a very long time. ~Gathering~ Prelude Welcome& Announcements Introductory Poem: As we step into Lent, we say “welcome” to the dissonance. “We reserve a space for lament and grief to stay a while and do their work. We release our nice little pictures of perfect selves, perfect faith, perfect world, and look for God in the heartache. We listen for God in discordant melodies and follow Jesus to the cross, though we don’t understand and it doesn’t compute.” As we step into Lent, we say, “welcome” to the dissonance, trusting that God is here, now, in the mystery, before it is resolved. Focus Statement: This week, our attention turns to the cast of characters beyond Jesus at his “trial.” Notice the roles various people play in this horrible moment. We are faced with our dissonance when we feel powerless, complicit, innocent, or accused. Hymn of Dissonance: VT 48 Come, My Way, My Truth, My Life (This hymn was chosen for its dissonant harmonies as well as for the words. Today we will sing all verses.) Call to Worship: All: Welcome Lent— WL: terrible dissonance, as we condemn the Human One. All: Welcome lament and confession WL: as the story comes undone. All: Welcome holy mystery WL: that even this can find a place in the tale of God’s salvation. All: Welcome suffering love and grace. Invocation Hymn of Gathering: HWB 37 Praise to the Lord ~Praising & Praying~ Prayers of the People Confession Poem: All: Jesus, things don’t always turn out the way we expect. Or want. And sometimes your choices (or the choices of our neighbors or family members or politicians) really don’t agree with us. Reader 1: We hate to admit it, but we feel for the angry crowd. In our fury, we too can become so consumed, so focused on who or what we are opposing, that we turn away from the things that matter most. Reader 2: “We have no king but the emperor!” we find ourselves saying. And only after we hear our voice do we realize how distorted our allegiance has become. God, have mercy. Christ, have mercy. Ending Prayer Hymn of Praise: HWB 66 O Worship the King ~Hearing God’s Word~ Scripture: John 19:1-16a Message: “ Seeing Jesus, the Suffering, Tortured, Dying One” ~Responding~ Time of Silence and Reflection: You are invited to write your thoughts on the paper provided. After three minutes of quiet reflection, the piano will play a hymn during which the offering plates will be passed into which you will place your papers. Hymn of Response: VT 325 O Sacred Head, Now Wounded (the offering will be collected and brought forth at this time) Offering Prayer ~Sending~ Benediction Sending Hymn: HWB 259 When I Survey the Wondrous Cross Postlude Sending Words WORSHIP 9:30-10:30 Minister: Mike Gehman Worship Leader: Dan Hostetler Pianist: Suzanne Stauffer Song Leader: April Shupe Usher: Leadership Team Lent 2026 – “Dwelling in Dissonance” This Lenten season we are choosing to stay in the uncomfortable, the unsettled or unfinished, the times that grate or jar or disturb and to try not to force those times to come to completion. Just as Jesus endured the trials of Holy Week, we too are committed to wait and to fully experience the dissonance in our lives. The worship services during this season will attempt to help us be more comfortable with the dissonances—as reflected in the altar, the music, in the book of John on which our services will focus, and in those disturbing times in our lives. After the sermon during Lent, there will be a three-minute period where we will be writing our thoughts about one of the questions printed on the bulletin insert. When the three minutes are over, the offering plates will be passed for you to put your paper in the plate to be taken to the altar. Please put your pen on the seat beside you so that we can continue to use them each Sunday in Lent. FMC LIVES IN DISCIPLESHIP TOGETHER Mission Project for March: MCC Hygiene Kits Keeping clean is an important part of staying healthy. Families who have fled their homes because of disaster or war often struggle to afford the necessary supplies. Kits also go to schools or orphanages to encourage healthy habits for children. A list of items needed is on the table in the coffee and fellowship area. Fox is having a three-part Biblical event starting tonight at 8 p.m . called The Faithful: Women of the Bible. Each episode follows the journey of five women of faith: Sarah, Hagar, Rebekah, Leah, and Rachel. THE CHURCH GIVES THANKS FOR Mike Keim: Jim Cahill continues to do well. THE CHURCH PRAYS FOR Mike Keim: Chris went into a fib yesterday and needs our prayers. April Shupe: Karissa’s mom fell and broke her shoulder. She had her shoulder replaced. Linda Yoder: Mom had blockage of 95% and had a stint put in. Dan Hostetler: Nate Miller has passed away. THIS WEEK March 23rd Happy Birthday, Craig Maurer UPCOMING EVENTS April 2nd Maundy Thursday Supper and Communion Service, 6pm April 5th Easter Sonrise Service, 8 am Easter Service, 10 am NEXT WEEK: Guest Minister: Darcy Miller Worship Leader: April Shupe Head Usher: Leadership Team LAST WEEK Attendance: 19 Offering: $140 Change for a dollar: $11 CHURCH LEADERSHIP Pastor’s Hours: Wednesday 9:30 am-2:30 pm Church Secretary: Tabatha Murphy Church Phone: 1-330-852-2822 Email: office@firstmennonitesugarcreek.com Website: http//fmcsugarcreekoh.org Address: 113 W. Main St. P.O. Box 250 Sugarcreek, OH 44681 CONGREGATIONAL LEADERSHIP TEAM: Chairperson: Mike Keim Office Contact: Linda Yoder Mission Contact: Reno Stevanus Trustees Contact: Dan Hostetler Secretary Contact: Amy Stauffer-McNutt
March 13, 2026
The body content of your post goes here. To edit this text, click on it and delete this default text and start typing your own or paste your own from a different source.
February 27, 2026
The body content of your post goes here. To edit this text, click on it and delete this default text and start typing your own or paste your own from a different source.
February 20, 2026
The body content of your post goes here. To edit this text, click on it and delete this default text and start typing your own or paste your own from a different source.
February 13, 2026
The body content of your post goes here. To edit this text, click on it and delete this default text and start typing your own or paste your own from a different source.
February 6, 2026
The body content of your post goes here. To edit this text, click on it and delete this default text and start typing your own or paste your own from a different source.
January 23, 2026
The body content of your post goes here. To edit this text, click on it and delete this default text and start typing your own or paste your own from a different source.
January 17, 2026
The body content of your post goes here. To edit this text, click on it and delete this default text and start typing your own or paste your own from a different source.
January 9, 2026
The body content of your post goes here. To edit this text, click on it and delete this default text and start typing your own or paste your own from a different source.